Growing up in middle America in a suburb of Tulsa, I attended a mainstream United Methodist church. We were fairly involved, attending about every other week. I had a personal faith and a community that loved me unconditionally. I had no experience with a church or personal life that put strict boundaries on what I could do or be due to my gender. As I got older, I began encountering people who had a different view of gender and faith. With the advent of cable, Christian television grew in popularity. As a result, a more fundamental view of Christianity became present in our society. I was shocked to realize that people judged me and my faith harshly and found it wanting.
Fast forward thirty years and we now live in a society where in many arenas women and men are treated equally and given the same rights, responsibilities and opportunities. However, in Oklahoma at least, the debate about women continues. The rise of the idea that a godly woman would reflect the qualities of Proverbs 31. Books and businesses have embraced this with gusto, often distorting the idea until it no longer reflects reality.
Rachel Held Evans grew up in a very fundamental environment. She embraced the lifestyle and community provided by her church life entirely. She provided leadership as appropriate within her tradition and flourished. However, as she grew older and continued to explore her faith, her experiences and education challenged the lifestyle that she had been living. She eventually would grow away from that tradition as she grew towards a new relationship with God. She began to realize that the literal expression of the Bible that she had been taught was actually filtered through the lives and opinions of the church leaders.
In A Year of Biblical Womanhood, Held Evans chronicles the year that she took scripture about women and lived it literally. In doing this she exposes the hypocrisy that is present in the Proverbs 31 culture and challenges others to really look at why they are living the way they do and what the Bible actually says about their lifestyle. Held Evans has faced a great deal of hostility by the Christian community. They follow her blog and other writings with a fervor that borders on obsession. Just waiting for her to say something they disagree with and jumping on her with an intensity that would lead many to flee from Christianity. Having read her previous writings, I looked forward to reading this book and chuckling at her witty insight. I was so disappointed that she was forced to defend her writing on the internet and on television.
I shared this book with a group of women from my church and was so comforted to experience it in a similar way. We all found it educational and enlightening and full of humor. We had honest conversation about what scripture actually says about being a woman and found much common ground. One of the women enjoyed it so much that she is going to present it in a first person book review to other women’s groups this year. I find it slightly troubling that she feels compelled to pick and choose what parts to share in an effort not to offend anyone. I hope that as we grow in our faith, we will be open to reading the scripture ourselves and honestly reflecting on what they mean.